Shirataki noodles are konjac glucomannan and water, which is why they carry almost 0 calories. That single fact is also their 1 real limitation.
They are close to a pure fibre gel. Two things follow: they are a genuinely low-calorie swap, and they contribute almost nothing nutritionally.
Quick Answer: Are Shirataki Noodles Healthy?
They are a low-calorie swap rather than a health food. Shirataki noodles are mostly water and konjac glucomannan, so they supply almost no calories, protein, vitamins or minerals. The fibre itself has real evidence for LDL cholesterol across 12 trials, and no good evidence for weight loss when tested directly as a supplement.
Key Takeaways
- Shirataki noodles are 2 things: konjac glucomannan and a lot of water.
- They supply close to 0 calories, protein, vitamins or minerals.
- The same fibre lowered LDL cholesterol across 12 trials in 370 people.
- As a supplement it produced 0 weight difference in an 8-week trial.
- They work as a calorie swap, not as 1 of the nourishing foods.
Related Products
What They Are Made Of
The ingredient list is short enough to explain everything about them.
- Main ingredient: Konjac glucomannan.
- Second ingredient: Water, and a great deal of it.
- Sometimes: A little calcium hydroxide to set the gel.
- Calories: Close to 0 per serving.
That is the same fibre sold in capsules, in a different physical form, and what it does is set out in the konjac overview page.
The Honest Nutritional Picture
Being almost pure fibre and water cuts both ways.
| What they give you | What they do not |
|---|---|
| Volume and bulk in a meal | Protein |
| Viscous soluble fibre | Vitamins and minerals in any quantity |
| Very few calories | Energy, which matters for some people |
| A pasta-shaped vehicle for sauce | The nutrition of the food they replace |
Swapping pasta for shirataki removes calories and also removes the carbohydrate, protein and micronutrients that came with it, which is fine occasionally and worth noticing as a habit.
Do They Help With Weight
The calorie arithmetic is real. The fibre-specific claim is not.
- Calorie swap: Genuine, and it is simple substitution.
- Fibre effect: 0 weight difference in the 8-week supplement trial.
- Fullness: Also no significant difference in that trial.
- So: The benefit is the swap, not the konjac.
In 53 adults taking 1.33 g of glucomannan before each of 3 meals for 8 weeks, weight change was 0.40 against 0.43 on placebo, with no difference in hunger or fullness either.[1]Safety and efficacy of glucomannan for weight loss in overweight and moderately obese adults — Journal of Obesity (2013) View source The full reading is in whether it helps with weight.
The Practical Complaints
Most people who dislike shirataki dislike 2 specific things, and both are fixable.
| Complaint | What helps |
|---|---|
| The smell on opening the packet | Rinse thoroughly under cold water |
| Rubbery or slippery texture | Dry-fry in a hot pan for a few minutes |
| No flavour of their own | That is the point; use a strong sauce |
| Feeling unsatisfied afterwards | Add protein, which the noodles do not supply |
Rinsing and dry-frying are the 2 steps that change most people's opinion, and neither takes more than a few minutes.
Eating Them Regularly
The safety questions are the same ones the capsules raise, in a milder form.
- Chew properly: The gel is firm and does not break up easily.
- Drink with the meal: As with any high-fibre food.
- Young children: Konjac jelly sweets are the real hazard, not noodles.
- Balance: Do not let them displace protein in a meal.
The full safety picture, including the konjac jelly recalls, is in what the safety data shows.
Noodles or Capsules
They are the same fibre in 2 formats, and they answer different questions.
| As a food | As a fibre supplement |
|---|---|
| Almost 0 calories per serving | 1000 mg of glucomannan per capsule |
| No measured amount | A measured amount every time |
| Fills a plate | Lowered LDL across 12 trials in 370 people |
| Chew properly | Take with a full glass of water |
The same glucomannan lowered LDL across 12 randomized trials in 370 people.[2]A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials of the effect of konjac glucomannan, a viscous soluble fiber, on LDL cholesterol and the new lipid targets non-HDL cholesterol and apolipoprotein B — The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2017) View source
In type 2 diabetes, 6 trials in 440 people found fasting glucose down 1.08.[3]Effects of Glucomannan Supplementation on Type II Diabetes Mellitus in Humans: A Meta-Analysis — Nutrients (2023) View source
- For a meal: The noodles, which are food.
- For a measured dose: The capsule, at 1000 mg.
- For LDL or glucose: Either, consistently.
If the fibre itself is what you are after rather than a pasta substitute, a 1000 mg capsule delivers a measured amount and takes a full glass of water with it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are shirataki noodles actually healthy? +
They are a low-calorie swap rather than a health food. They supply close to 0 protein, vitamins or minerals of their own.
Is it safe to eat shirataki noodles every day? +
For most adults, yes, with normal chewing and fluid. The 1 group to be careful with is young children, and the real hazard there is konjac jelly sweets.
What is the downside to shirataki noodles? +
They displace whatever they replace. Swapping pasta removes calories and also removes the 2 things that came with it, protein and micronutrients.
What do shirataki noodles taste like? +
Almost nothing, which is the point. The 2 usual complaints are the smell on opening and the texture, and both respond to rinsing and dry-frying.
What is the healthiest noodle for weight loss? +
As a calorie swap shirataki is hard to beat at close to 0 calories. As nutrition it contributes the least of any noodle.
Do shirataki noodles fill you up? +
Some people find they do. In a controlled trial of the same fibre, hunger and fullness showed no significant difference over 8 weeks.
Why do they smell when I open the packet? +
It is the packing liquid rather than the noodles. Rinsing under cold water for 1 minute removes it almost completely.
Are they keto friendly? +
They contain almost no digestible carbohydrate, so they fit most low-carbohydrate patterns. That is 1 reason they became popular.
Do they count towards fibre intake? +
Yes, as a viscous soluble fibre. That is the same fibre that lowered LDL across 12 randomized trials in 370 people.
Can children eat them? +
Cut noodles are generally fine with supervision. Konjac jelly mini-cups are the 1 format linked to choking incidents in young children.
Are capsules better than noodles? +
For a measured fibre dose, yes. For a meal, the noodles are food and the capsule is not, so the 2 answer different questions.
Related Reading
Related Products
